Water Heater Timer Savings and When They Are Worth It
An electric water heater keeps a full tank hot around the clock, including the eight hours you are asleep and the nine you are at work.

An electric water heater keeps a full tank hot around the clock, including the eight hours you are asleep and the nine you are at work. A water heater timer promises to stop paying for that, but whether it saves $20 a year or $300 depends almost entirely on how your electricity is priced and how old your tank is.
I have looked at a lot of home energy bills, and water heating is usually the second or third biggest line after heating and cooling. Here is how a timer works, what it really saves, and the safety points to settle before anyone touches a 240 volt circuit.
How a water heater timer works
A standard electric tank heater has one or two heating elements, often rated 4,500 watts each, controlled by thermostats. When the water cools below the set point, an element switches on until the tank is back up to temperature.
A timer sits between the breaker and the heater and cuts power to the elements during hours you choose. The water already in the tank stays hot for many hours because the tank is insulated. When the timer switches power back on, the heater recovers to its set temperature.
There are three main types:
- Mechanical 240 volt timers: a wall box with a dial and trippers, rated for 30 to 40 amps. Usually $60 to $90.
- Digital programmable timers: the same job with weekday and weekend schedules. Often $80 to $150.
- Smart controllers: app controlled, sometimes with energy monitoring, and some utilities offer them free or discounted under demand response programmes.
An ordinary plug-in timer is not suitable. Tank heaters are hard wired on a dedicated 240 volt circuit, usually with a 30 amp breaker, and the timer must be rated for that load.
What a water heater timer actually saves
Savings come from two places. The first is standby loss, the heat that leaks through the tank walls while nobody uses water. The second, and much bigger, is shifting when the heater draws power if your utility charges more at certain hours.
| Situation | Rough yearly savings |
|---|---|
| Newer, well insulated tank, flat rate | $15 to $35 |
| Older tank (15 years plus), flat rate | $30 to $60 |
| Any tank on a time of use rate | $100 to $300 or more |
| Home empty most weekdays, flat rate | $40 to $80 |
On a flat rate, the math is modest. A newer 50 gallon tank might lose 1 to 1.5 kWh a day in standby heat. A timer that cuts power for eight hours overnight trims part of that, perhaps 120 to 180 kWh a year. At 17 cents per kWh, that is about $20 to $30.
On a time of use plan, the picture changes. If peak power costs 35 cents and off-peak costs 12 cents, every kWh of water heating moved out of the peak window saves 23 cents. A household using 8 kWh a day for hot water that shifts most of it off-peak can save well over $200 a year. Our guide to time of use electricity rates explains how those windows are set.
Cheaper changes to make first
A timer is not the first thing I would buy. These steps cost less and often save as much:
- Lower the thermostat to 120°F (about 49°C). Many tanks leave the factory at 140°F. Each 10 degree drop cuts standby loss by roughly 3 to 5 percent. Turn off the breaker before removing the element cover panels.
- Insulate the first 6 feet of hot pipe leaving the tank, using foam sleeves that cost a few dollars.
- Fix dripping hot taps. One drip a second wastes over 3,000 gallons a year, much of it heated.
- Fit low flow shower heads rated at 1.8 gallons per minute or less.
If you are not sure how much your water heater uses, start by finding the appliances driving up your power bill with a few simple meter readings.
Why "turn it off when you don't need it" is not always right
The common advice is that a water heater timer always saves energy because the heater is "off" for hours. That is only partly true, and it can lead people to schedules that save nothing.
When the timer switches power back on, the heater has to reheat all the water that cooled during the off period. Some of the energy you thought you saved gets spent at that moment. On a modern, well insulated tank, the standby loss is small enough that the difference can be close to zero.
A timer also creates new problems if the schedule is wrong. Cut power during the morning shower window and the family runs out of hot water. Set very long off periods and the tank can sit for hours in the 70 to 110°F range, which is the temperature band where Legionella bacteria grow. Keep the tank at 120°F or above for at least part of each day, and do not schedule off periods longer than about 10 to 12 hours. If you are on a flat rate with a newer tank, a lower thermostat setting is usually the better trade.
Installation and safety
A water heater timer is wired into a 240 volt circuit that can deliver 30 amps or more. This is not a plug-in gadget, and mistakes can cause a shock or a fire.
- Have a licensed electrician install it. Expect $150 to $300 for labour on a straightforward job.
- The timer must be rated for the heater's full load and match the circuit voltage.
- Check that the breaker is the correct size for the wire, and that the heater is properly grounded.
- Heat pump water heaters have their own scheduling settings. Use those instead of an external timer, which can interfere with the compressor.
- If you rent, ask the landlord before any change to hard wired equipment.
After installation, compare a month of usage before and after. Our guide on how to read your electric meter shows how to take accurate readings.
Frequently asked questions
Is it cheaper to leave a water heater on all the time?
On a flat electricity rate with a modern tank, the difference is small, often under $30 a year. On a time of use rate, switching it off during peak hours can save much more. Check your tariff before deciding.
Can I install a water heater timer myself?
It involves working on a 240 volt, 30 amp circuit, so a licensed electrician is the safe choice. Some areas also require a permit for this work. A wrong connection can cause overheating or shock.
How many hours a day should an electric water heater run?
Most tanks only heat for two to four hours a day in total, spread across the day as water is used. With a timer, give it at least two powered windows, one before morning use and one before evening use, so the tank is fully reheated.
More in Saving Energy
Saving Energy
What the Lights in Your Home Actually Cost to Run
A reader wrote in convinced her lights were the reason her bill had climbed.
Saving Energy
Fridge Running Cost and When an Old One Is Worth Replacing
The fridge is the one appliance in your home that never gets a day off.
Saving Energy
Space Heater Running Cost and How to Keep It Low
You bought a space heater to take the chill off one room, and then the electric bill arrived $50 higher than last month.